There is an image reproduced at the beginning of this book. It looks at first glance to be a photocopy, so stark is its contrast and so unclear its details, though it is in fact an image taken with a pinhole camera. It shows the author John Berger standing beside the first of the many people he writes about in this book, an artist who lives alone in the countryside. Very little can be seen of their surroundings, just the hazy silhouettes of a tree and the artist’s house. The figures themselves are silhouetted also, their features and clothes indiscernible, their smiles unseen. And yet the tenderness that exists between the two people is clear. Her head leans towards his, his body supporting hers like a sturdy tree trunk. And you can just make out the unkemptness of the author’s hair, as though such trivialities as appearance have been thrown to the wind.
It is not only a wonderful portrait, but a carefully chosen one, it being the visual equivalent to the writing that follows. For the writing, like the photograph, conveys so much about its subjects with so little. There are around thirty ‘chapters’ here, each one just a few pages in length, and each one being about a person who touched Berger’s life in some way.
He writes about a particular memory of each person, a memory that in same way defines that person’s essence, in the way that a portrait can. It reminds me of the drawings of Rembrandt, or Maggi Hambling. Those artists capture the essence of their subjects often with just a few strokes of the pen, and Berger writes with a similar economy. There isn’t a single superfluous word in this book. Take one word out of any of these portraits and the likeness would be lost, yet if you were to add one word more, it would stick out like an ugly ink blot.
Take Berger’s description of a Parisian photographer, now begging in the Metro:
“His eyes are an intense pale blue, and from time to time they twitch, as a dog’s muzzle twitches when investigating a scent. Its hard to watch his eyes without feeling you’re being indelicate. They’re totally exposed – not through innocence, but through an addiction to observation. If eyes are windows on to the soul, his have neither panes nor curtains, and he stands in the window frame and you can’t see past his gaze.”
Or this, his description of a motorcyclist about to mount his bike during a race:
“[he] puts on his helmet and stands very still, waiting, small, a shearwater looking out to sea from a cliff edge.”
Berger’s own humanity shines through every page, as does his respect for those he writes about. One of the most moving of all these moments is the one in which he visits a prison and reads a story to one of the prisoners, a man he has never met before but whose predicament leaves a lifelong impression on the author:
“The aim of incarceration is to reduce all exchanges with the outside world to a minimum. And this has an effect on voices. Ours, as we read, were unlike prisoners’ voices. Our voices were volatile – like swallows in flight seen through a window. Maybe our voices were more interesting than the story we were reading.”
The book is full of such acutely observed insights. And of course, this being Berger, a lot of these insights are into the nature of Art, its relationship with the people he describes and also with himself.
“A wisp of grass is blown onto one drawing. Tiny fruit flies alight on another. A scrap of leaf, transparent like parchment, drifts from a nearby field of maize on to another sheet. If I did not see these things being wafted on to the paper I would have mistaken them for painted marks. I’m no longer at all sure where to draw the line between art and nature, Becoming and Origin. This is the mystery that keeps me peering even after the light has dimmed and the chickens have gone quiet.”
I like this passage particularly as it goes some way to describing his own writing. It is hard to draw the line between the people he describes and the nature that surrounds them. People are closer here to their animal cousins than in anything else I’ve read. The motorcyclist who is a shearwater on a cliff edge, the photographer whose eyes twitch like a dog’s muzzle, or the artist who learns about her nature through cuttlefish, octopus and molluscs. It feels like some kind of distilled astrology, but one based on observation and earthy truths rather than the muddled light of the stars above.
But above all, the collective whole of these portraits becomes a celebration of individuality, and of shared humanity. You feel you would love to meet every person in this book, and you’re left, invariably, with the feeling that you have had that pleasure. Insightful, tender and wise, it is one of the most life-affirming reads I can think of, and one to return to again and again.
“The two of us stood there facing the camera. We moved of course, but not more than the plum trees did in the wind. Minutes passed. While we stood there, we reflected the light, and what we reflected went through the black hole into the dark box.
‘It’ll be of us’, she said. And waited expectantly.”


